Climate Change: not all black and white | Reportage Online
Home » GEJI

Climate Change: not all black and white

19 May 2010 16 Comments
By Sofia Levin | Melbourne Editor


Murrundindi

Murrundindi holding bread fungus. Image: Sofia Levin

Fire abatement projects are successfully using traditional burning techniques to combat greenhouse gas emissions.

However, at the same time these projects are highlighting the lack of understanding about climate change in Indigenous Australian populations.

Deputy Director of Monash University’s Centre for Australian Indigenous Studies Professor John Bradley is concerned about the gap between Western and Aboriginal knowledge of climate change.

“I’ve been in communities and had people come up to me and say, ‘what’s this climate change thing?’ It has not even been identified yet as a priority to educate indigenous people,” Professor Bradley said.

But communication is a difficult process.

Professor Bradley speaks two Aboriginal dialects and neither have a word that represents anything close to the Western notion of ‘climate.’

Wurundjeri elder, Murrundindi is just one indigenous Australian who denies the existence of climate change, despite The State of Climate snapshot released recently by the CSIRO and the Bureau of Meteorology that stated climate change is real.

“I’m not into global warming and all this garbage. I just believe in the old way, the old people,” Murrundindi said.

The snapshot showed a continual decrease in rainfall in southern areas of Australia. But Murrundindi relies on Mother Nature to counter the report’s warnings.

“I’ve been noticing out in the bush a lot of bread fungus growing…it doesn’t usually come out until the winter, and it came out in the summer. That tells us to be prepared; we are going to have a lot of rain,” he said.

Indigenous Australians have survived enormous environmental changes such as the end of the ice age eleven thousand years ago and the flooding of the Arafura plain between northern Australia and New Guinea.

Based on their resilient history, some Aboriginal organisations have started to realise that traditional methods of land management are invaluable to helping Australia slow the rate of climate change.

Employment opportunities are being provided to Indigenous Australians because of climate change, whether they believe in it or not.

Darwin Liquefied Natural Gas pays indigenous fire managers around $1 million a year to stage controlled burns under fire abatement projects in Northern Australia. Since 2006, the project’s land managers have cut CO2 emissions by 488,000 tonnes due to reduced bushfires in West Arnhem Land.

As well as supplying opportunities for Aboriginal people to work ‘on country’ with controlled burning, some land management projects provide online information to educate indigenous Australians about how they are caught up by climate change.

According to the CSIRO, savanna burning in Australia releases a similar amount of CO2 to all Australian industrial sources and transport.

Murrundindi believes that indigenous controlled burning could have prevented the Black Saturday bushfires that occurred in early February last year.

He said the government ignored the pleas of Aboriginal people and blames poor land management for the 173 deaths in last year’s fires.

Professor Bradley said that Indigenous Australians are more than happy to be paid for controlled burning, something they have done for almost fifty thousand years.

He said a minority of Indigenous Australians view fire abatement as a solution to the release of CO2, as the Western scientific concepts that surround climate change are difficult for Aboriginal people to grasp.

This lack of understanding about climate change presents threats to indigenous populations, especially when forecasts are predicting that they will suffer the most from the effects of climate change when compared to other, more urban populations.

The Australian Government’s Department of Climate Change released a report early this month documenting the risks to Indigenous Australians posed by climate change.

The risks included an increase in extreme weather events, heightened disease and health complications, disintegration of ecosystems and entire species, and the possibility of forced migration due to rising sea levels, amongst other potential hazards.

The report emphasises the importance of Professors Bradley’s plea for programs to educate indigenous Australians about climate change.

At present, most indigenous populations see climate change as “…just whitefellas’ thinking.”

Share |
  • http://planetaryvision.blogspot.com Paul Clark

    The arrogance from the climate change crew toward these elders is stunning. Australia has always had cycles of drought and rain. The current drought in southern Australia is caused by the Indian Ocean Dipole. Researchers know this but instead put it down to the new bandwagon in town: global warming.

    If an Aboriginal elder from the bush says nothing new is happening with climate and everything is normal, here’s an idea: why don’t we listen to him instead of condescendingly push some “education” on to them to teach them what computer models in the city say should be happening?

  • http://planetaryvision.blogspot.com Paul Clark

    The arrogance from the climate change crew toward these elders is stunning. Australia has always had cycles of drought and rain. The current drought in southern Australia is caused by the Indian Ocean Dipole. Researchers know this but instead put it down to the new bandwagon in town: global warming.

    If an Aboriginal elder from the bush says nothing new is happening with climate and everything is normal, here’s an idea: why don’t we listen to him instead of condescendingly push some “education” on to them to teach them what computer models in the city say should be happening?

  • R James

    I have to agree with Paul. The aboriginals know more about what the climate does, and how to adapt, than all the scientists. If we look closely at actual data, we find that, at least for Australia, nothing unusual is happening with climate. Long term rainfall data shows that we are just in normal cycles. “At present, most indigenous populations see climate change as …just whitefellas thinking.” Once again, they’re right.

  • R James

    I have to agree with Paul. The aboriginals know more about what the climate does, and how to adapt, than all the scientists. If we look closely at actual data, we find that, at least for Australia, nothing unusual is happening with climate. Long term rainfall data shows that we are just in normal cycles. “At present, most indigenous populations see climate change as …just whitefellas thinking.” Once again, they’re right.

  • Pingback: Climate Change even more dangerous for Aborigines « Nuclear Australia

  • Peter Morgan

    Climate Change isn’t weather. Climate change is not caused by the poor or disenfranchised but by the rich and wealthy who think only in the short-term. The next election cycle, the next soundbite.
    If there is a culture with a long term view of history surely Aboriginals would be one. So it is disheartening to think of the impact of climate change on our most marginal citizens, it is even sadder to read the above comments. Surely a culture that has survived for so long and in the last two hundred years in particular has put up with so much would know that preparation is key to survival. Its our fault but it is their problem.

  • Peter Morgan

    Climate Change isn’t weather. Climate change is not caused by the poor or disenfranchised but by the rich and wealthy who think only in the short-term. The next election cycle, the next soundbite.
    If there is a culture with a long term view of history surely Aboriginals would be one. So it is disheartening to think of the impact of climate change on our most marginal citizens, it is even sadder to read the above comments. Surely a culture that has survived for so long and in the last two hundred years in particular has put up with so much would know that preparation is key to survival. Its our fault but it is their problem.

  • http://www.earthfacts.net Susan Earth

    I also agree with Paul that this article has a condescending tone. It is implied that the aboriginals don’t believe in climate change because they are uneducated.

    I would be very surprised if aboriginals, with their long tradition of oral history, do not have an understanding of climate, even if they don’t use the same word for it as scientists do.

    And there are “educated” westerners who are also skeptical about climate change.

  • http://www.earthfacts.net Susan Earth

    I also agree with Paul that this article has a condescending tone. It is implied that the aboriginals don’t believe in climate change because they are uneducated.

    I would be very surprised if aboriginals, with their long tradition of oral history, do not have an understanding of climate, even if they don’t use the same word for it as scientists do.

    And there are “educated” westerners who are also skeptical about climate change.

  • Amanda Hoh

    I agree with you Susan, there has been a lack of voice from aboriginal communities throughout the climate change debate. They have such a close affiliation with the land that their perspective is extremely interesting and insightful.

  • Amanda Hoh

    I agree with you Susan, there has been a lack of voice from aboriginal communities throughout the climate change debate. They have such a close affiliation with the land that their perspective is extremely interesting and insightful.

  • http://www.marblecleaningmiami.com/fl-marble-floor-cleaning-coral-gables.html marble polishing coral gables

    I also agree with the article. Climate Change isn’t weather. Thanks for sharing this.

  • http://www.terrazzorestoration.net/ Terrazzo Floor Repair

    great site.i would like to come back again.

  • http://www.moldremoval.com/f.florida-mold-removal-contractor.cape-coral.33904.html Mold Removal Cape Coral

    Climate change is not caused by the poor or disenfranchised but by the rich and wealthy who think only in the short-term.Thanks.

  • http://www.terrazzofloorpolishing.net Restoring Terrazzo

    Climate Change: not all black and white! Good article!

  • http://www.terrazzorestoration.net Polishing Terrazzo MIAMI-DADE

    Fire abatement projects are successfully using traditional burning techniques to combat greenhouse gas emissions.